Joey Buttafuoco Became Famous When His Teen Girlfriend Shot His Wife. Where Is He Now?

Joey Buttafuoco was involved in a huge tabloid scandal in the 1990s when he had an affair with a sixteen-year-old.

Rivy Lyon
2 min readMay 17, 2024
Joey Buttafuoco and his new girlfriend, Ryanne Joey in 2024. Tiktok/Ryanne Joey

To learn the full story, read my article on All That’s Interesting.

It all started on May 19, 1992, when a 17-year-old girl named Amy Fisher rang the doorbell and shot Joey Buttafuoco’s wife Mary Jo in the face at her home in Long Island, New York.

That girl was Buttafuoco’s secret girlfriend. He was 35 at the time.

While he was sentenced to six months for statutory rape, and she was charged with attempted murder, Buttafuoco’s wife, Mary Jo, survived the ordeal and stayed with her husband, despite her better judgment.

Eventually, the couple got divorced in 2003 after he was arrested for soliciting an undercover cop. However, the scandalous life of Joey Buttafuoco didn’t end there.

Insurance fraud, pornographic movies, and a very public rekindling with his past lover thrust him back into the media spotlight… and he seemed to be enjoying the attention.

To learn the full story, read my article on All That’s Interesting. Click on the link above this article. It’s free to read!

--

--

Rivy Lyon
Rivy Lyon

Written by Rivy Lyon

Investigative Journalist | Criminology, Psychology & Sociology B.A. | I’ve loved true crime since Forensic Files was Medical Detectives!

Responses (6)